Arches             Mesa Verde National Park, Colorado              DeathValley

Required Viewing and Reading

  1. NPS / Mesa Verde National Park / Geology of Mesa Verde (pdf) - Required
  2. Wikipedia / Mesa Verde
  3. USGS / Virtual Tour
  4. Text -Geology of National Parks:  Mesa Verde, pp. 91-102
  5. filmThe Archeology Channel: Mesa Verde: Legacy of Stone /Mesa Verde Burns

Key Words and Themes

wikiglobe

Terms: alcove, caprock, mesa, canyon, weathering, groundwater, exfoliation, sandstone, shale, Cretaceous Interior Seaway  

Formation: Cliff House Sandstone of the Mesa Verde Group

Archeology: Anasazi (Ancestral Puebloans)

 

Click to view in a larger map

Figure 1. Mesa Verde National Park (northeast of the For Corners), Colorado is located on the western edge of the Colorado Plateau against the eastern flank of the Southern Rockies.  The park incompasses a numerous canyons carved into a thick sequence of uplifted Cretaceous sediments.  The ancient Puebloan Indians built their cliff dwellings in natural alcoves carved into the canyon walls by weathering.

Introduction to the Park

Objectives

  • Describe the lithology and environment of Formation of the Mancos Shale and Cliff House Sandstone.
  • Explain the formation of the Interior Seaway. What tectonics events were responsible?
  • Explain the origin of the name Mesa Verde.
  • Discuss what makes Mesa Verde unique and why the area is worth perserving as a National Park.
  • Explain the formation of natural alcoves.
  • Discuss how the Ancestral Puebloans utilized the geologic.
  • Define the following terms; caprock, mesa, contact spring, alcove,  and exfoliation and discuss their significance.

Mesa Verde

Mesa Verde is a flat deeply dissected upland (fig. 2) ranging from 7000 to 8,500 feet in elevation. The tableland dips gently southwest and is underlain by ~3000  feet of Cretaceous-age shales and sandstones. Tributaries of the Mancos River have carved the plateau into numerous elongate mesas, such as Chapman Mesa, Wetherhill Mesa, and Long Mesa (fig. 2). Both the surfaces of the mesas and the walls of the canyons were occupied by the ancestral Pueblo (formerly Anasazi) Indians. Although they inhabited Mesa Verde from around 600 AD through 1300 AD, they only built and lived in cliffhouses during the last 80 years of this occupation, between 1200 and 1280 AD.  Approximately 600 cliff dwellings are located in the canyons of Mesa Verde. Tours of some of the larger dwellings are available to the public, however most are inaccessible. To reach Mesa Verde drive north 6 miles from Cortez, CO, located in the Montezuma Valley at the foot of the Mesa.  From there it's  25 miles to the visitors' center along a road that switchbacks up the 2000-foot steep face of the North Rim.  The drive offers spectacular views of the verdant valley below, and a close look at the stratigraphy of shales and sandstone deposited in the Interior Seaway that flooded the western craton during the Cretaceous Period. The soft shales and thin-bedded coal and sandstones create a very unstable slope, as observed from the numerous landslide scars and slope-stabilization structures along the road.

park map
Figure 1. Map of "Mesa" Verde National Park and its canyons carved by tributaries of the Mancos River.  The Mancos flows in to the San Juan River, which is tributary to the Colorado River.  As the Colorado carves deeper so also do the rivers flowing into it.  Mesa Verde is actually a large plateau or tableland capped by the Cliff House Sandstone. The ancestral Pueblo Indians lived on the surface and in cliff dwellings along the canyon walls. The park, which is covered by a pinion and juniper forest, has been protected from agriculture, wood harvesting, and grazing since the National Park Service took over in 1906.  The combination of thick forests and dryer than normal climatic conditions has resulted in many large fires that have destroyed historic structures on the mesa's surface. For more information read Fire History at Mesa Verde.  The road to the park climbs (from Route 160) two thousand feet up the North Rim along a series of dramatic (and yes, scary) hairpin turns.  (Click on map to enlarge.)
Mesa Verde
Figure 3. Mesa Verde lies along the foot of the San Jan Mountains and is composed of sediments shed from rising (ancestral) highlands into the Mancos Sea.   

Sedimentary rocks of  Mesa Verde

Marine, coastal, and terrestrial (land-based) sedimentary rocks comprise the ~3000 feet of Cretaceous strata underlying the plateau.  Most of these were deposited in or along the margins of the Western Interior Seaway  that flooded the continent during the Cretaceous Period. From the bottom to the top, the geologic formations composing the tableland are the Mancos Formation (marine shale), Point Lookout Formation (coastal sandstone), the Menefee Formation (terrestrial shale, sandstone and coal deposits) and the Cliff House Formation (coastal sandstone).   The latter three formations are part of a larger geologic unit known as the Mesa Verde Group, which is noted for its coal deposits.   The Cliff House Sandstone, and locally the Point Lookout Formation (fig. 4), comprise the mesa's protective caprock. Once eroded the weak Menefee and Mancos formations rapidly disintegrate.  Uplift and tilting within the last 20 million years has created the present upland and initiated incision by south-flowing streams (fig. 1).    The cliff dwellings occupy the walls of these narrow stream-carved canyons. Despite the mesa's high elevation its southerly orientation offers a longer growing season than the broad valley (Montezuma Valley) to the north.  This proved to be  an important advantage to the Indians growing crops on its surface.

north slope
Figure 4.   Looking northeast from Park Point view along the North Rim of Mesa Verde.  The white layer near the top is the Point Lookout  sandstone protecting the easily eroded Mancos shale beneath.  Note how quickly the shales is eroded into badlands and removed once the caprock is removed.

Why the Cretaceous Seaway?

View image from the Paleontology Portal.

It may seem hard to imagine how the ocean could flood the western craton (from Alaska to the Gulf of Mexico) to produce an inland sea.  Two events made the west susceptible to flooding during the Cretaceous Period.  First sea level was higher. Pangea was breaking up and rates of sea-floor spreading and subduction were quite high. When sea-floor spreading is fast ocean basins are occupied by warmer, more buoyant oceanic crust.  The sea floor is therefore higher and water is displaced onto low-lying continental regions.  Also, high rates of tectonic activity mean increased volcanism, and emission of magmatic CO2 that warms the atmosphere--hence no glaciers to retain water on land.  The second factor promoting flooding was the collision and consequent over-thrusting of island-arcs onto the western edge of the continent. Loading of the continental margin produced a subsiding trough, as the crust east of the collision flex downward (subsided) under the load.  (Press a finger into your arm and observe the trough that forms around it.)  These events produced an inland sea that transgressed and regressed with changing conditions, depositing stacked layers of shale, sandstone, and coal.  The warm moist conditions of the time also resulted in high biological productivity and the accumulation of coal-producing organic matter.

Soda Canyon
Figure 5. Typical Mesa Verde canyon. Balcony house (hidden below the ledge) is located in the Cliff House Formation exposed here in Soda Canyon.

 

Early Inhabitants

  The remains of ancestral Pueblo Indian communities lie scattered across the mesa surface.  However, the most amazing structures are the remains of  complex cliff dwellings tucked away in natural alcoves along the walls of the deep canyons cutting through the mesa. The Ancient Pueblo People (Anasazi or Hisatsinom) began building in alcoves around 1200 A.D. and then mysteriously abandoned around 1280 A.D.  Considering the short period of time these cliff dwellings were occupied, the amount of effort that went into building them was tremendous. There are approximately 600 cliff dwellings on Mesa Verde.  The largest is Cliff Palace (fig. 12) which housed over 200 people had over 150 rooms and 23 kivas.  Other cliff houses in the Park include Spruce Tree house (fig. 13) and Balcony House (figs. 7-11)  Why the ancestral Pueblo Indians built the cliff dwellings and then abandoned them soon after is slowly being revealed (Kohler, 2008).  During a time of extreme drought Mesa Verde became attractive to Indians living in the Four Corners region. It's higher elevation offered slightly cooler and wetter conditions. An increasing population density may have resulted in the occupation of the less desirable canyon walls, and as resources became more scarce the dwellings would offered greater protection from a decreasingly stable society.  After decimating the local deer population the ancestral Pueblo Indians relied on raising turkeys to satisfy their protein demands.  Because maize was the principle food source for both the people and their turkeys the collapse of agriculture, driven by drought, forced the ancestral Pueblo people to migrate to south and west.  Although there is currently no indication of violence on Mesa Verde, evidence of warfare and cannibalism at the nearby Castle Rock Pueblo (see The Final Days) emphasizes the harsh conditions that must have existed at the time and the need to move on.

Most of the cliff dwellings are located in natural alcoves etched by weathering (fig. 10) in the Cliff House Sandstone (fig. 6). The sandstone forms the protective upper part of the mesa and forms buff-colored cliffs along the canyon walls.  Spaced throughout the Cliff House Formation are thin layers of shale that trap and deflect the flow of water, thereby aiding in the formation alcoves (fig. 6 and 10). 

Alcoves Formation and Occupation

The cliff dwellers of Mesa Verde National Park, Motezuma's Castle National Monument, and Canyon De Chelly National Monument took advantage of the unique conditions afforded them by the horizontal strata, deep canyons, and hydrology of the Colorado Plateau.  Sandstone is permeable, which means that groundwater flows through it readily. Shales on the other hand are impermeable.   Water percolating vertically through thick porous sandstone is deflected laterally upon reaching an underlying shale bed (fig. 3) until it escapes through fractures or where the bedding intersects the cliff face. Contact springs (figs. 10 and 11) or seeps develop. The moisture slowly dissolves the cement binding the sandstone forming a hollow around the seep.  It's here where weathering and mass-wasting processes are most active and where alcoves develop. Once a hollow is formed unloading stresses take over and exfoliation (fig. 7) becomes the dominant process in shaping the alcove. The ancient Puebloans expanded the alcoves by removing loose debris and then built walls and dwellings with slabs of the local sandstone.  Limy mud was used as mortar. The alcoves not only provided protective sites for housing, but were often supplied with a source of water

 

Alcove Formation

Figure 6. Alcove formation in the Cliff House Sandstone.

 

How do the alcoves at Mesa Verde Form?

a. Surface water percolates vertically through the porous sandstone until a thin shale layer is encountered. 

b. Because shale is impermeable water is directed laterally along it's surface and eventually discharged in springs along the cliff face (figs. 6, 10, 11). This process starts dissolving the cement in the overlying sandstone.  Salt precipitated from evaporating water further acts to weather the rock.

c. The alcove is created by solution weathering (removal of the sandstone's calcareous cement) accompanied by other weathering processes, such as frost wedging, and salt weathering (fig. 10).  Alcoves are further shaped and enlarged by exfoliation and mass wasting.

 
Balcony House
Figure 7. Balcony House is one of many cliff dwelling that occupies a natural alcove in the Cliff House Formation.  Note the large arched exfoliation joints shaping the geometry of the alcove.
Balcony house interior
Figure 8. Interior of Balcony House.  The sandstone, which naturally cleaves along bedding, and was easily formed into dwellings.  The the circular pit in the foreground is a ceremonial kiva.  Dark stains on the ceiling is soot from fires burned in dwellings and ceremonial kivas.  Dendrochronology is applied to the cross beam to determine the age of construction and prevailing climatic conditions.
ripples
Figure 9. The natural floor of Balcony house is covered with fossil beach ripples attesting to the nearshore and coastal depositional environment of the Cliff House Sandstone.  The principle food staple for the inhabitants was corn, which they ground with stones, such as those shown resting on the floor.  Teeth from remains of ancient Puebloans show extensive wear caused by silica ground into the corn from grinding stones, and decay, attributed to the high sugar content of corn.  The Puebloans' life expectancy was around 40 years.
shale spring
Figure 10.  Weathering processes at work. In the back of the Balcony House alcove is a thin shaly layer were water percolating down through the sandstone naturally collects and flows until it discharges along the cliff face. Several weathering processes operate here that cause the alcove formation.  First, the discharging groundwater dissolves the sandstone cement and loosens the grains;  second, cycles of wetting and drying, and freeze-thaw disintegrates the shale;  third, salts contained in the water are precipitated (white rind) further breaking up the rock; and last, removal of material causes the rock to expand and exfoliate to form the arcuate alcove (fig. 7).  Unfortunately weathering did not halt with the discovery of the cliff dwellings.  The Park System is in constant battle with the forces of nature to prevent further decay and roof collapse.

 

spring
Figure 11.  Balcony House spring.  This fairly large spring pool behind the 2-story square building in figure 8 also provided water. Without such springs the Indian would have to carry the water up the steep cliff face hundreds of feet.
Cliff Palace
Figure 12. Cliff Palace has the greatest number of rooms

 

Spruce Tree
Figure 13. Spruce Tree House.

 

Content Exercise

1. Describe the landscape of the park. Use the terms mesa, caprock, alcove, and canyon and name the two smaller mesas in which the cliff dwellings are located.  What river and its tributaries are responsible for carving the park's canyons?

2.When and how long were the cliff dwellings occupied?  What probably drove the cliff dwellers from Mesa Verde?

3. Described the natural conditions and resources that enabled the ancient Puebloans to build and live along the canyons of Mesa Verde.

4. Describe how the alcoves in Mesa Verde were formed.  What roles did groundwater, shaly layers, and exfoliation play in their formation?

5. The sedimentary rocks of Mesa Verde were formed within and along the Interior Seaway of North America.  Describe the age, and the conditions leading the formation of the seaway. List and describe three geologic formations formed during this time.

 

Other sites to explore and references

stop and take test
  Return to your myWebCourses home page to take Section D Quiz

On to Section E : Death Valley National Park onto Death Valley

Lindley Hanson/Department of Geological Sciences/Salem State College/QkRef